Debate over fights in hockey continues

Last February’s Penguins-Islanders game degenerated into an all-out brawl — literally.

Fighting in hockey has been argued for decades and there is no end in sight. Those who support fighting argue it keeps the game honorable and is a fan and television ratings attraction, while its critics view it as pointless and barbaric.  

Among the strongest advocates for the elimination of fighting in the game is   The Hockey News columnist Adam Proteau. He is the author of a soon-to-be-released book that challenges the NHL to clean up its on-ice product titled “Fighting The Good Fight: Why On-Ice Violence Is Killing Hockey.”
“It’s what I consider the exceptionalism that says ‘We’re different from all those other sports.’ The NFL, where guys will grab each other’s testicles in a scrum, somehow that’s less manly or less forceful than what happens in the NHL. I don’t buy it,” Proteau told Metro by phone this week. “It’s an unnatural part of hockey.”

The website Hockeyfights.com reports there have been 34 fights in the first 74 games this year, and it projects that there will be 565 fights by the end of the 2011-12 regular season. Moreover, there have been 3,754 fights in the 7,448 regular season games that have been contested, as of this writing, since the lockout. That works out to an average of one fight every two games.

“Guys are bigger, stronger, faster every year. You take away where the guys can police the game themselves then it’s going to be a bunch of stick work,” Islanders enforcer Trevor Gilles said following practice at Nassau Coliseum Tuesday. “It’s important that guys know that they have to be held accountable for taking liberties with star players.”
 
His words echoes those of Toronto Maple Leafs General Manager Brian Burke at the NHL Board of Governors meeting in June. When asked by Metro about the state of fighting in the NHL, Burke replied, “Even people like me, who are pro-fighting, are happy with where fighting is and don’t want to see its role expanded. The place fighting has in our game is that players do self-police.”
 
It is a rationale that Proteau vehemently disputes.
 
“I don’t buy any of that Brian Burke talk and I like Brian. He’s part of the hockey establishment that believes hockey is exceptional [compared to other major professional sports],” Proteau said. “I don’t buy the self-policing angle either because it’s always the so-called policeman in the game they’re the ones that wind up snapping, whether it’s Trevor Gillies or Chris Simon in the past, or some people might say Matt Cooke is a policeman. Derek Boogaard, when he was alive, he was certainly a policeman. They’re the ones that go off and take a baseball swing or stomp down on somebody’s skate.
 
“I just think this idea that there’s this Wild West romanticized ethical code that all hockey players live by is nonsense.”
 
Last Feb. 11, the Penguins and Islanders played in a game where they combined for 342 penalty minutes, 15 fighting majors and 10 game misconduct penalties in the Islanders’ 9-3 win. 

It was a game that left a black eye on the NHL. 

“I don’t think many people really thought it was right or it was hockey; obviously it was a game that had a lot of emotion. I guess that’s the way it kind of worked out,” said Islanders center John Tavares. “I think that game is in its own kind of category. Obviously, that was a little bit over the top and really
wasn’t much of a hockey game after the first half.”

While Tavares acknowledged the public outcry that emanated in the aftermath of the now-infamous game, he views the enforcer as someone who is in the sport for the foreseeable future.
 
“I think your linemates create you more [scoring] opportunities, but the ability an enforcer has, to make sure you’re not being taken advantage of in certain situations, is a big role. They’re there to protect you in a sense,” Tavares said. “Fighting is part of the game and I think we all believe it should stay. I think [if] you ask other players, for the most part, believe in it as well. Obviously not everyone is a fan of it but it’s been in the game for so long.”

Follow Metro’s NHL writer Denis Gorman on Twitter @DenisGorman for coverage of all the area teams.



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

MAP: New York City Street Closures August 22,…

The Percy Sutton Harlem 5K and NYC Family Health Walk-a-thon and Pakistan Day Parade and Fair will cause traffic delays and street closures in New York City this weekend. Plan…

International

U.N. nuclear inquiry on Iran seen making slow…

The U.N. nuclear watchdog appears to have made only limited progress so far in getting Iran to answer questions about its suspected atomic bomb research, diplomatic sources said on Friday,…

National

Violence-weary Missouri town sees second night of calm

By Nick Carey and Carey GillamFERGUSON Mo. (Reuters) - The violence-weary town of Ferguson, Missouri, saw a second straight evening of relative calm on Thursday…

National

Journalist James Foley's parents, after call with pope,…

The parents of James Foley, the American journalist killed by Islamic State militants in Iraq, on Friday called for prayer and support to free the remaining captives held by Islamic…

Television

Recap: 'The Knick,' Season 1, Episode 3, 'The…

The third episode of Steven Soderbergh's "The Knick" finds Dr. Thackery (Clive Owen) meeting an old flame and other characters embracing self-destruction.

Music

Webcast: Watch Polyphonic Spree live on Sunday Aug.…

Polyphonic Spree singer Tim DeLaughter sits with Metro Music Editor Pat Healy for a chat and then the big band performs live. It begins on Sunday at 9:30 pm

Movies

Matthew Weiner on directing 'Are You Here' and…

"Mad Men" creator Matthew Weiner discusses his movie "Are You Here," his history writing comedy and the tiny movie he directed in 1996 you can't see.

Movies

Michael Chiklis on his football past and 'When…

Michael Chiklis remembers playing football in high school and how that prepped him to play a coach in "When the Game Stands Tall."

NFL

3 things we learned about the Giants in…

The Giants claimed the Snoopy trophy in a battle of MetLife Stadium tenants Friday night. But more importantly, the offense finally showed some life in…

NFL

3 things we learned about the Jets in…

The Jets lost the Snoopy Bowl, 35-24, to the Giants, losing the trophy and local bragging rights.

NFL

Fantasy football draft guide: How to draft your…

Many are wondering if we’re entering a new age in fantasy football drafting — one where running backs take a backseat.

NFL

Jets vs. Giants: 3 Giants storylines to watch

The Giants have plenty to work on as they reach the dress rehearsal preseason game Friday night against the rival Jets.

Sex

Big weddings may lead to long-term happiness

Dreaming of a big wedding? A new study indicates that the longer your guest list, the happier you’ll be in the long run. l A…

Sex

Online dating for every generation

Frank Jackson and his mother Maggie are like lots of modern families: They have dinner together regularly, keep each other updated on their lives —…

Wellbeing

Going green could be the key to getting…

If we could just pursue the things that would actually make us happy, we could help the environment too, according to a New York researcher.…

Tech

Siren: A new dating app that puts women…

Online dating can be brutal, especially for single women. Noting that many women hate wading through inappropriate messages and photos, two tech entrepreneurs decided to…