Theater: ‘When We Were Young and Unafraid’ starts strong, ends overblown

When We Were Young and Unafraid
Agnes (Cherry Jones, right) alternately comforts and confronts a battered housewife (Zoe Kazan) in MTC’s “When We Were Young and Unafraid.”
Credit: Joan Marcus

Despite some overblown flourishes, like a trap door in the stage, Sarah Treem’s “When We Were Young and Unafraid” begins with promise. It’s 1972. Agnes (Cherry Jones) runs a bed and breakfast on an island off Seattle and, aided by her daughter Penny (Morgan Saylor), hides and shelters battered wives as they begin to construct new lives.

In (through the trap door, of course) walks one such victim, Mary Anne (Zoe Kazan). Her face is bruised and in need of stiches, but she’s hardly down for the count. Initially tentative, she turns out to be quite a handful and a catalyst for chaos. The tension promisingly mounts, but spins out of control. By Act II the drama has degenerated into pure soap opera, complete with an actual pregnancy, a possible pregnancy, a revelation and a predictable budding romance, all accompanied by the requisite histrionics and grandstanding.

As Agnes, the always-reliable Jones seems as sturdy as the Early American furniture in her sitting room, but even she has a breaking point. Kazan, who pulls together bad girl Mary Anne’s many strains — selfish, guileless, self-destructive, needy — shows her seemingly fragile character to be perhaps the stronger of the two. She has more contradictory layers, which Kazan illuminates with perverse intensity. If Agnes carries the play, Mary Anne pushes it along. It’s too bad it doesn’t really go anywhere meaningful.

A product of good dramatic instincts that got lost along the way, “When We Were Young and Unafraid” is a study in dramatic excess, consistently using a torch when a candle would do.

If you go

‘When We Were Young and Unafraid’
Manhattan Theatre Club,
NY City Center Stage I
131 West 55th St.
$95, 212-581-1212,


Black and white are the new orange at…

By Brendan O'Brien(Reuters) - Black and white are the new orange in a Michigan county where the sheriff has made a wardrobe change for jail…


Traps set after reports of giant snake on…

New Jersey animal control workers have set traps to snare a reported 20-foot-long serpent slithering through the waters of Lake Hopatcong.


Pro arm wrestler calls himself real-life 'Hellboy'

You can call German arm-wrestler Matthias Schlitte "Hellboy."

Breaking: National

Tsarnaev pal Azamat Tazhayakov guilty in bombing obstruction…

Tazhayakov, a Kazakh exchange student, was the first of three of Tsarnaev's friends to be charged with interfering in authorities' investigation.

Going Out

Hot Chef: London Grill in Fairmount changes with…

Since 1991, Michael McNally has been the chef and co-owner at Fairmount's London Grill. There are some aspects that McNally has adapted to keep with…


‘The Leftovers’ recap: Season 1, Episode 4, ‘B.J.…

Last week’s episode of “The Leftovers” was apparently a fluke, because this week’s episode returns to focusing on the Garveys and it is so boring.…


Interview: Luc Besson says 'Lucy' is very different…

Filmmaker Luc Besson talks about his new film "Lucy," how it's different than "Limitless" and his crazy first conversation with Egyptian actor Amr Waked.


Weezer releases first new song since 2010

Weezer releases "Back to the Shack," their first new song in almost six years.


Angelo Cataldi: Eagles will win Super Bowl this…

On Feb. 1, 2015, Philadelphia’s 55-year wait for an NFL championship will end. The Eagles will win the Super Bowl. I’m pretty sure.


'Vicktory dogs' travel road to rehabilitation seven years…

Of the dozens of dogs groomed by Bad Newz Kennels, 48 were rescued and 22 of the pit bull terriers have emerged at Best Friends Animal Society.


Yankees looking at trade for Cliff Lee, according…

Yankees looking at trade for Cliff Lee, according to report


Phillies' Marlon Byrd firmly on MLB trade market

Phillies' Marlon Byrd firmly on MLB trade market


RocketSkates let users roll with a motor

Los Angeles company Acton has raised funds on Kickstarter to roll out a nifty alternative – motor-powered "RocketSkates."


Knicks star Carmelo Anthony becomes a tech entrepreneur

He's been an All-Star, an Olympian, and a celebrity spokesperson. Now NBA player Carmelo Anthony is adding the position "tech entrepreneur" to his resume. Along…


Ulises 1 is the world's first singing satellite

A group of artists and engineers in Mexico have unveiled Ulises 1, the world's first opera-singing satellite.


Wallscape on a budget

Skip the wallpaper and ombre an accent wall instead.