Is Vince Young better than Kevin Kolb?

Vince Young during a game the Redskins in 2010.

When it comes to the backup quarterback position, the Eagles just exchanged their old one for a promising cornerback and a second round draft pick. And now they may have picked up an even better one through free agency.

Yes, Vince Young has some personal issues he needs to work out — writer Mike Tanier describes him as “emo Michael Vick” — but on the actual football field, could you make the case that Young is better than the man he’s replacing?

Let’s look at some stats, conventional and otherwise.

As a caveat, we’re not going to compare the statistics brought up the most today: Young’s 30-17 record as a starter to Kolb’s 3-4. Everyone knows this but we still have to say it: Quarterback wins is a lousy stat too dependent on outside factors!

(Also, Kolb’s stats are a little less trustworthy, because of the small sample size. Nothing we can do about that!)

Passer rating: The pair are fairly evenly matched in terms of career passer rating, with Young at 75.7 and Kolb at 73.2. Not great for either of them! But that might not be an accurate assessment, including as it does Kolb’s “throw him into the fire” start against the Ravens in 2008 and Young’s rookie year when he was still getting adjusted. So let’s look at the last two years, when both QBs were getting pulled in and out of the starting lineup by the fickle hand of fate. In 2009, Young’s rating was 82.8 in 12 games, while Kolb’s was 88.9 in five games. In 2010, the places switched: Young put up a rating of 98.6 in nine games, while Kolb fell down to 76.1 in seven games.

Yards/Attempt: Yards/Attempt isn’t that much better of a stat than passer rating, but we want to spotlight something: In 2010, Vince Young put up a Y/A average of 8.0. (League leader Phillip Rivers put up 8.7.) Kolb, by comparison, put up 6.3 yards per attempt over the season. Of course, Kolb put up 7.7 in 2009, so we’re probably just cherry-picking.

But now let’s go to advanced stats! These are all going to be complicated and we won’t be able to explain them, but we might as well look!

Adjusted Net Yards/Attempt: This is Pro Football Reference’s efficiency stat that takes into account sacks, interceptions and touchdowns. It paints much of the same picture as passer rating does: Kolb was a little better than Young in 2009 (6.7 to 6.4), but a fair amount worse in 2010 (5.4 to 7.3).

DVOA: Let’s finish up with Football Outsider’s rate state, Defense-Adjusted Value over Average. DVOA compares a player’s success with the expected success of an average player at his position in the same situation. As a warning, even though DVOA loves the Eagles, it hates Kevin Kolb as a passer, rating him at 16% better than an average quarterback in 2009, and 3% worse than an average QB in 2010. Vince Young, by contrast, had a DVOA of 17% in 2009 and was up to nearly 27% in 2010. (This is only for passing; for rushing Young was a tad below average both years, while Kolb was slightly better than average in 2009 and way below in 2010. Like we said, small sample size.)

So, what have we learned? Most stats agree that both were about as good in 2009, but either Kolb regressed or Young took a step forward in 2010. Or a little of both! Give Young Kolb’s supporting cast and why couldn’t he be better?

Except: The lockout. Considering that Kolb had spent years in the Eagles system when he got his shot, while Young will likely have had only a few months, we think probably not. But that won’t stop us from hoping Andy Reid and Marty Mornhinweg can help Young eventually become Baby Mike Vick, a dual-threat quarterback with deadly deep accuracy.



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Mayor announces public housing improvements

Mayor Bill de Blasio spoke at the Lincoln Houses in East Harlem on Wednesday, calling for the scaffolding to come down at NYCHA complexes across…

National

Peter Theo Curtis: American released by Syrian militants…

An American writer freed this week from two years in the captivity of insurgents in Syria spoke briefly outside his family's Cambridge home Wednesday of…

Local

Bratton defends 'broken windows' work as NYPD support…

Sixty percent of those polled said they support the "broken windows" theory approach popularized by Commissioner Bratton since his first term in the 1990s.

Local

Transit changes for Labor Day weekend

The MTA is adding additional service Friday for New Yorkers getting out of the city for the long weekend. On Friday, Aug. 29, 27 additional…

Television

'So You Think You Can Dance' recap: Season…

Season 11’s top four dancers gave their final performances before America’s Favorite Dancers are announced next week.

Going Out

Things to do this week in NYC, Aug.…

MUSIC The Electric Zoo Festival Aug. 29-31, 1 p.m. Randall’s Island Park $99-$369, www.electriczoofestival.com The electronic music celebration returns for a fifth year, with 150,000 attendees…

Going Out

5 things to do this weekend in NYC

The Electric Zoo Festival Aug. 29-31, 1 p.m. Randall’s Island Park $99-$369, www.electriczoofestival.com The electronic music celebration returns for a fifth year, with 150,000 attendees expected. David Guetta,…

Television

'Full House' might be relaunched with some of…

A new "Full House" might be in the works.

NFL

Mario Manningham on the bubble as Giants play…

Former Super Bowl hero Mario Manningham hopes his second go-around with Big Blue doesn’t end with Saturday’s final cut day.

NFL

Source: Stephen Hill 'faces a battle' to make…

A team source says Stephen Hill, who has battled injuries and poor performances during his first two years, is no lock to make the Jets’ final roster.

Sports

Serena Williams leaving legacy of talented American women…

It seems only a matter of when, not if, Serena Williams will win her 18th career grand slam championship.

College

When are 2014 college football playoffs? (Schedule, date,…

When and where are 2014 college football playoffs? A look at the schedule, date, TV, time for the semi-finals at championship game.

Food

Recipe: Samuel Adams beer-marinated grilled shrimp

Summer calls for two things: a cold beer and light food. Sam Adams' Latitude 48 IPA fairly bursts with citrus notes, making it an ideal marinade…

Wellbeing

Heart trumps brain when it comes to movies…

When you need a good cry, do you reach for the movie that’s “based on a true story”? Science says you’re giving your brain far…

Sex

The 10 types of people you meet online

Does it ever seem like online dating profiles tend to get a little repetitive? It turns out you are not the only one to have…

Home

Labor Day essentials

Whether you’re soaking up the sun on the beach or barbecuing in the park here are some must-haves for your end-of-summer bash.