NY judge throws out lawsuit by Empire State Building investors

The Empire State Building is pictured through a rain-splattered window in Manhattan. Credit: Getty Images
The Empire State Building is pictured through a rain-splattered window in Manhattan. Credit: Getty Images

A New York state judge has thrown out a lawsuit in which longtime investors in the Empire State Building claimed they were shortchanged out of hundreds of millions of dollars by the real estate magnates who took the iconic skyscraper public last October.

In a decision made public on Monday, Justice O. Peter Sherwood of the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan said the investors waived their right to sue Peter Malkin and his son Anthony when they agreed in May 2013 to settle earlier claims over the building’s fate for $55 million.

The December 2013 lawsuit accused the Malkins of acting in bad faith before the IPO by aborting a “bidding war” for the property, spurning all-cash offers of up to $2.3 billion for the building and $1.4 billion for Empire State Building Associates LLC (“ESBA”), which held the title and master lease.

Instead, the plaintiffs, suing on behalf of more than 2,800 ESBA investors, said the Malkins tried to inflate the value of 17 lesser properties they controlled by packaging them and the building into Empire State Realty Trust Inc, a real estate investment trust.

They said the REIT’s Oct. 1 initial public offering valued the Empire State Building at just $1.89 billion, and ESBA at a mere $1.1 billion.

Sherwood, however, said the plaintiffs had “asserted the same claim (breach of fiduciary duty) against the same defendants concerning the same transaction,” despite having accepted a “covenant not to sue” in the earlier settlement. “As such the current claim is barred.”

John Rizio-Hamilton, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, said: “We disagree with the court’s recitation of the facts and application of the law, and our clients will determine the next steps.”

Thomas Dewey, a lawyer for the Malkins, said: “We are gratified by the court’s decision.”

ESBA was created in 1961 by Lawrence Wien, the father-in-law of Peter Malkin, and shares were sold privately. It had been supervised by a Malkin company, Malkin Holdings LLC, which was succeeded by Empire State Realty Trust.

Opened in 1931, the Empire State Building has been featured in movies including “King Kong” and “Sleepless in Seattle.” It was the world’s tallest building for about four decades, until it was passed by the original World Trade Center’s north tower.

Empire State Realty Trust went public at $13 per share, the low end of the forecast range. The stock closed up 15 cents at $16.45 in Tuesday trading on the New York Stock Exchange.

 



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Gunther from 'Friends' talks Central Perk

We spoke with Gunther (James Michael Tyler) at the preview for new pop-up Central Perk, based on the cafe in "Friends."

Local

Central Perk opens in SoHo

Central Perk, of "Friends" fame, is giving out free coffee in SoHo through Oct. 18.

National

Beer sponsor Anheuser-Busch reproaches NFL over domestic abuse

Anheuser-Busch chastised the NFL for its handling of domestic violence cases, making it the first major advertiser to put pressure on the league.

Local

Sen. Krueger dishes on prospect of legal marijuana…

New Yorkers may see the legalization of recreational marijuana use as early as 2015 if State Senator Liz Krueger (D) gets her way. The Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act will…

Music

FREEMAN makes Freeman a free man from Ween

For nearly 30 years, Aaron Freeman was known endearingly to his listeners as Gene Ween. But with "FREEMAN," he makes it clear that he's gone somewhere else.

Television

'Outlander' recap: Season 1, Episode 6: 'The Garrison…

Whipping, punching, kicking and a marriage contract. "Outlander" is not for the faint of heart this week with "The Garrison Commander."

The Word

The Word: Hey girl, it's a girl for…

It's a girl for Ryan Gosling and Eva Mendes, who reportedly welcomed a daughter last Friday, according to Us Weekly. The super-private couple managed to…

Television

TV watch list, Tuesday, Sept. 16: 'New Girl,'…

Check out the season premiere of "New Girl," as Jess competes with Jessica Biel for a guy's attentions.

MLB

5 top contenders for NL Rookie of the…

The outing rekindled award talk for deGrom, who appears to hold the top spot for NL Rookie of the Year honors. Metro breaks down a few other contenders.

College

College football Top 25 poll (AP rankings)

College football Top 25 poll (AP rankings)

NFL

Tom Coughlin says Giants 'beat themselves' against Cardinals

Head coach Tom Coughlin, who had a day to cool off and reflect, still sounded like he had a gnawing feeling in his gut.

NFL

Marty Mornhinweg accepts blame for Jets timeout fiasco

Jets fans looking for a scapegoat for Sunday’s timeout fiasco found a willing party on Monday: Marty Mornhinweg.

Style

Rachel Zoe: New York Fashion Week Spring 15

Rachel Zoe goes 'Glam bohemia' for Spring.

Food

Where to find SweeTango apples

Introduced in 2009, SweeTango — a hybrid of Honeycrisp and Zestar — is a sweet apple with plenty of crunch.

Style

London Fashion Week recap

London Fashion week gets in on the action with politics, heritage and summertime living.

Food

Padma Lakshmi's recipe for green mango curry

Padma Lakshmi shares her recipe for green mango curry in UNICEF's new book, "UNICHEF."