City’s top architecture firms offer visions of a new Penn Station

A view of 7th Avenue, in the world of H3 Hardy Architecture's new Penn Station. See Metro's slideshow for all four architecture firms' visions of a new Penn Station and a new Madison Square Garden. Credit: H3 Hary Architecture.
A view of 7th Avenue, in the world of H3 Hardy Architecture’s new Penn Station. See Metro’s slideshow for all four architecture firms’ visions of a new Penn Station and a new Madison Square Garden. Credit: H3 Hardy Architecture.

Four of the city’s top architecture firms Wednesday morning unveiled design ideas for a new Penn Station—and a separate Madison Square Garden.

The renderings are part of a design challenge put out by the Municipal Arts Society, which has joined with the Regional Plan Association to form the Alliance for a New Penn Station.

The firms, SHoP Architects, H3 Hardy Architecture, SOM, and Diller, Scofidio + Renfro, handpicked by MAS, had less than two months to come up with their designs, according to Vin Cipolla, MAS president.

“There are many great firms in the city,” Cipolla said. “But these four in particular have worked in very, very complex urban contexts, and all four have experience with this particular part of Manhattan.”

The architects behind the renderings presented today spoke excitedly about the prospect of redesigning the largest transit hub in North America.

“This is a once-in-a-century opportunity to right the wrong of what happened to Penn Station,” said SHoP principal architect Gregg Pasquarelli, “to get Penn Station out from being a basement space and give it the kind of space and civic nature that is appropriate for the busiest train station in the United States.”

SHoP’s design is airy and bright, with soaring ceilings letting in natural light, quite the opposite of the current Penn Station. In their proposal, a hyper-modern, almost futuristic Madison Square Garden is moved over to the site of a mail storage facility a few blocks away—not the iconic 8th Avenue post office.

SHoP Architects' vision of a new Madison Square Garden. Credit: SHoP Architects.
SHoP Architects’ vision of a new Madison Square Garden. Credit: SHoP Architects.

John Fontillas, a partner at H3, was most excited at the opportunity to ready Penn Station for the advent of high-speed rail—an inevitability, he said.

With Boston or D.C. 90 minutes away on high-speed rail, Fontillas said, “you could go to Boston, have a business meeting, and be back in time for dinner.”

“It makes Penn Station the center not just of the city but of the entire east coast, the entire Northeast Corridor,” he enthused.

“We’re New Yorkers,” said Fontillas. “Why do we have to settle for something that’s second-rate, that’s substandard?”

H3 envisions Madison Square Garden at a waterfront location near the Javits Center, capitalizing on the proximity to tourists and convention-goers and making “a new identity for the Garden.”

H3's imagining of a waterfront Madison Square Garden. Credit: H3 Hardy Architecture.
H3′s imagining of a waterfront Madison Square Garden. Credit: H3 Hardy Architecture.

Both Fontillas and Pasquarelli emphasized the economic benefit to the area.

“Yes, it would cost money, but the real estate value that you would unlock… would be immense to us,” Fontillas said.

“The most sustainable thing you can do is not to hang solar panels all over your building or have hybrid cars, but to put [population] density next to mass transit,” Pasquarelli explained. “The fact that you have a completely underbuilt area around the busiest transit station in the country in a travesty.”

SHoP’s design would ultimately pay for itself, Pasquarelli explained.

“Our project not only looks at making great and inspiring designs but also looks at how to pay for them by… unlocking the development rights which is not only a smart, sustainable, green objective,” he said, “you can [also] use the tax dollars generated there to pay for the infrastructure of the station.”

The plans are ambitious in their design, but also in their very existence—while the operating permit Madison Square Garden had for that location has expired, they are now applying for a permit that would allow them to remain above the train station permanently.

MAS and the architects behind these designs say that such a permit would kill any hopes of ever turning Penn Station into a 21st century train station.

An aerial view of Diller Scofidio + Renfro's Penn Station at night. Credit: Diller Scofidio + Renfro.
An aerial view of Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s Penn Station at night. Credit: Diller Scofidio + Renfro.

The Alliance is pushing for MSG to receive a 10-year term permit, also recommended by Community Board 5, Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer and State Senator Brad Hoylman. They say this would give the Garden enough time to relocate and rebuild.

The City Planning Commission recently made a recommendation for a 15-year permit, which was at first encouraging to the Penn Station visionaries, until they discovered the recommendation contains a provision that would allow MSG to obtain an in perpetuity permit by striking a deal with the railroads that operate within Penn Station, requiring only the signoff of the planning department and no public review.

Cipolla dismissed resistance to a new Penn Station as cynical, and said the status quo is “completely unsustainable.”

“We cannot go on with Penn Station in its existing condition,” Cipolla said. “It’s environmentally unsafe, way over capacity, and cannot meet the needs of a growing population.”

A view of SOM's new Penn Station, from the steps of the 8th Avenue post office. Credit: SOM.
A view of SOM’s new Penn Station, from the steps of the 8th Avenue post office. Credit: SOM.

Cipolla noted that while the arena has been in its current location for 50 years, this is far from its original location: the Garden was first at the site of its namesake park, and then was moved to 50th Street and 8th Avenue before relocating to sit above Penn Station.

He stressed that MAS and the architects care deeply about the future of the Garden as well as the train station.

“We all love Madison Square Garden and want there to be a world-class arena in Manhattan,” he said. If the plan for a New Penn Station moved forward, and the Garden could be relocated and rebuilt, “Manhattan, like Brooklyn, would get a 21st-century arena.”

The next step in the process will be a public hearing with the City Council in June, where the Alliance hopes to persuade the Council to vote for a 10-year permit when the vote comes around in July.

 

Follow Danielle Tcholakian on Twitter @danielleiat



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

MTA announces service changes for Sunday

The MTA has announced service changes ahead of Sunday's People's Climate March, which will be held from 11:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Sunday. Riders using…

Local

NYPD launches Twitter account for L train

The NYPD recently launched a Twitter handle dedicated to the L train and its riders. According to @NYPDLtrain, officers went underground Thursday morning to hand…

Local

Bushwick community space offers activists a place to…

A new Bushwick community space offers community activists to meet, create, learn and throw back a few cold ones. MayDay, located 214 Starr Street in Bushwick,…

Local

Activists gearing up for Sunday's "historic" People's Climate…

If all goes according to plan, more than 100,000 people will gather near Central Park West on Sunday morning and march through midtown to raise…

Movies

Review: Terry Gilliam's 'The Zero Theorem' is better…

Terry Gilliam's latest, "The Zero Theorem," concerns a reclusive malcontent (Christoph Waltz) struggling with the search for the meaning of life.

Music

Esperanza Spalding and a being called Emily get…

Esperanza Spalding is about to spiral off in a brand new direction that may or may include an alter ego named Emily.

Movies

Review: Bickering family dramedy 'This is Where I…

A talented cast sits Shiva in the bickering family dramedy "This is Where I Leave You," although it's more sap than yuks.

Movies

Review: Desert-walking movie 'Tracks' would be better as…

Mia Wasikowska walks 1700 miles across Australia's deserts in "Tracks," in a story that defies triumph-of-the-spirit cliches but gets some of them anyway.

NFL

J.J. Watt poses unique challenges to struggling Giants…

Watt, arguably the best defensive player in the league, is the leader of a surprising Texans (2-0) team that has already matched last season’s win total.

NFL

Eric Decker 'unlikely to play' against Bears: Source

Jets wide receiver Eric Decker's status for Monday night’s game against the Bears is in doubt after he missed practice again Wednesday.

NFL

Preston Parker, not Odell Beckham, will replace Jerrel…

Tom Coughlin noted the next man up will be unheralded veteran Preston Parker.

NFL

NFL Week 3 full schedule (kickoff time, TV)

NFL Week 3 full schedule (kickoff time, TV)

Parenting

A sneaky way to serve kids fruits and…

"My First Juices and Smoothies" gives smoothie recipes for kids.

Style

3 things we love from Day 1 of…

The highlights from Day 1 of Milan Fashion Week.

Sex

Why don't more couples use condoms?

  Call it the “condom moment.” That’s the name the authors of a new study have given to the pivotal conversation every couple should be…

Sex

Need an idea for a first date? Here's…

Picture your idea of a nice first date. Is it dinner and a movie? A visit to an interesting museum exhibit? Instead, an expert on…