Woman kidnapped as baby from New York hospital can’t sue city: judge

 

Joy White holding picture of her baby Carlina White who was kidnapped from Harlem Hospital. (Photo by Clarence Davis/NY Daily News via Getty Images)
Joy White holding picture of her baby Carlina White who was kidnapped from Harlem Hospital. Credit: Clarence Davis/NY Daily News via Getty Images

A woman who was reunited with her family nearly 25 years after she was kidnapped from a New York City hospital cannot sue the city for damages, a state judge has ruled.

Carlina White, whose dramatic story spawned headlines and a Lifetime television movie, was taken from Harlem Hospital in 1987, when she was 19 days old, and raised by her kidnapper in Connecticut.

After essentially solving her own case and finding her birth parents, White sued the city for $2 million last year.

Manhattan state Supreme Court Justice Kathryn Freed, however, said that White could not sue because her parents had already done so on her behalf in 1988, reaching a $750,000 settlement that included money set aside for White if she were found before her 21st birthday.

Plaintiffs are barred from filing claims that have already been adjudicated.

“The court finds unavailing plaintiff’s argument that she was denied a rightful opportunity to sue because she was an infant when the federal action was commenced,” Freed wrote in a decision dismissing the case that was made public on Wednesday. “Indeed, plaintiff’s interests in the federal action were represented by her biological parents and their counsel.”

But Eugene Byers, a lawyer for White, said on Thursday that she had still not gotten her day in court. The city’s law department said in a statement that the court had reached the right decision.

White, who goes by the name Nejdra Nance, was raised by her kidnapper, Ann Pettway. When she turned 16, White asked for her birth certificate and other documents, and Pettway confessed that she was not White’s biological mother.

Pettway was convicted in Manhattan federal court and sentenced to 12 years in prison last summer. Meanwhile, in 2010, White noticed a photo of a missing infant that strongly resembled her own daughter and suspected that she was the child.

White contacted the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and DNA confirmed the link between her and her biological parents.

The 24-year gap between White’s kidnapping and her reunion with her family is one of the longest in non-parental abductions in history, according to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.

White’s relationship with her biological parents has since deteriorated, in part due to the media attention, according to Freed’s ruling. By the time White was identified, the trust money that had been set aside for her in the 1992 settlement had already been released to her parents, who had spent it.

(Reporting by Joseph Ax; Editing by Lisa Shumaker)



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Federal mediator joins Met Opera labor talks as…

Unions representing the orchestra and chorus of the Met Opera agreed to have a federal mediator join labor talks on Thursday as a threatened lockout loomed.

Local

Winning $7 million New York lottery ticket sold…

The only $7 million winning New York Lottery ticket for Monday's Cash4Life drawing was sold at a Queens 7-Eleven, officials said on Tuesday.

Local

Brooklyn man charged in roommate's stabbing death

A Brooklyn man accused of violently stabbing his roommate to death on Monday is in police custody and faces murder charges.

International

Dinosaurs could have survived asteroid strike

It turns out there is a good and a bad time for the planet to be hit by a meteor, and dinosaurs were just unlucky.…

Movies

Review: 'Guardians of the Galaxy' is a refreshingly…

Marvel is sitting so high on a cash mountain that it's now thrown $170 million at the relatively obscure and very silly title "Guardians of the Galaxy."

Movies

Review: 'Get on Up' is a war between…

James Brown finally gets his own boring biopic with "Get on Up," but the Godfather of Soul puts up a good fight against the usual cliches.

Movies

Review: 'Child of God' finds director James Franco…

James Franco's 11th directed feature is a noble but sloppy adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's "Child of God," about a feral mountain man (Scott Haze).

Movies

Review: Alex Gibney's Fela Kuti doc 'Finding Fela'…

Prolific documentarian Alex Gibney takes on Afrobeat god Fela Kuti in "Finding Fela," but fails to capture his unique essence.

MLB

Yankees land Stephen Drew, Martin Prado at trade…

Yankees land Stephen Drew, Martin Prado at trade deadline

College

Playing the Field: Valentine's Day coupling edition

  It’s Valentine’s Day, a day created by Hallmark to make couples spend loads and loads of money on candy, flowers and gourmet dinners. Or…

MLB

Angelo Cataldi: Ryan Howard deserves better from Phillies

Just last week, Ryan Howard endured the embarrassment of a benching that was inevitable, and yet still shocking.

NFL

Larry Donnell has inside track in Giants tight…

Little-known Larry Donnell of Grambling State currently has the inside track, as the second-year player has received the bulk of the first-team reps.

Career

What do you wear to a career fair?…

Getting that gig starts with presenting the most polished and memorable version of yourself, so refer to our expert fashion advice.

Style

Editors pick: Margiela's finger armor ring

These cool rings from Maison Martin Margiela are designed to overlap over the finger, covering each joint like armor.

Style

Givenchy champions diversity

Riccardo Tisci's uses a variety of ethnically diverse ladies for his spring campaign including Erykah Badu.

Wellbeing

Don't settle for the hotel fitness center with…

Travelers who want to skip the hotel fitness center in favor of local gyms that may offer better equipment, classes and amenities can turn to…