City responds after appeals court upholds strike-down of soda ban

NEWS_soda-rgb
The state-level appeals court upheld a lower court ruling that the ban on large sugary drinks would be an overreach of executive powers. Credit: Getty Images

After a state appeals court ruled the city’s plan to ban large sugary drinks is an illegal overreach of executive power, Mayor Michael Bloomberg vowed to not let a “temporary setback” stop the city from continuing its efforts to fight obesity.

“We firmly disagree with the court’s reasoning and will seek to appeal to the Court of Appeals as quickly as possible,” city lawyer Michael Cardozo said in a statement.

While the city cited “broad precedent” for the Board of Health to enact the ban, the board “failed to act within the bounds of its lawfully delegated authority” when it passed the measure, the First Department of the Supreme Court’s Appellate Division said in a unanimous decision Tuesday.

First announced by Bloomberg last year, the soda ban would cap the size of sugary beverages sold in restaurants and other eateries at 16 ounces. In March, a state court deemed the regulation invalid, calling it “arbitrary and capricious.”

In Tuesday’s ruling upholding the decision, the four-judge appeals court noted the ban was not put to a City Council vote, despite some members asking for one. Doing so was “violative of the principle of separation of powers.”

The appeals court also pointed out the ban had several loopholes, including exempting businesses not under the authority of the city’s health department, like grocery stores and chains.

“Accordingly, the selective restrictions enacted by the Board of Health reveal that the health of the residents of New York City was not its sole concern,” Judge Dianne Renwick wrote. “If it were, the ‘soda ban’ would apply to all public and private enterprises in New York City.”

Still, the city was defiant, pointing out sugary drinks have been linked to the obesity epidemic.

“Since New York City’s groundbreaking limit on the portion size of sugary beverages was prevented from going into effect on March 12, more than 2,000 New Yorkers have died from the effects of diabetes,” Bloomberg said in a statement.

The American Beverage Association, one group that petitioned the court to strike down the ban, was “pleased” the decision was upheld.

“With this ruling behind us, we look forward to collaborating with city leaders on solutions that will have a meaningful and lasting impact on the people of New York City,” said Christopher Gindlesperger, senior director of public affairs at the association.

Though the city will ask the Court of Appeals to look into Tuesday’s decision, the court can choose not to do so.

Follow Anna Sanders on Twitter: @AnnaESanders



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Mayor reveals new tech hub Digital.NYC

Mayor Bill de Blasio revealed Digital.NYC on Wednesday, a new online platform aimed at connecting all things tech in New York City. The public-private partnership…

Local

Falling debris hits two men in Times Square

Two men were taken to the hospital Wednesday morning after being hit by falling debris from 110 feet above Times Square. Nancy Greco from the…

Local

Queens Assemblyman William Scarborough accused of misusing campaign…

Queens Assemblyman William Scarborough has been indicted on state and federal charges for allegedly withdrawing campaign funds as cash for personal use. Scarborough, a Democrat…

News

U.S. Secret Service director Pierson resigns under fire

U.S. Secret Service Director Julia Pierson resigned under fire on Wednesday after a series of security lapses came to light.

Television

TV watch list, Wednesday, Oct. 1: 'Criminal Minds,'…

The "Criminal Minds" team adds some supernatural assistance, as the "Ghost Whisperer" herself, Jennifer Love Hewitt, joins the show. She's playing an FBI agent, but you never know when someone…

Music

See the most popular Pandora station in your…

Who knew Bachata music was so popular?

The Word

The Word: Twilight just won't die

You thought our "Twilight" days were behind us, didn't you? Well think again. Series creator Stephenie Meyer (who would rather you not ask about "Twilight"…

Going Out

Which NYC restaurant lost its three-star Michelin rating?

A record 73 restaurants in New York City collected coveted Michelin stars on Tuesday as a mix of trendy spots and fine-dining stalwarts underscored the…

NFL

Rex Ryan fields more questions about Geno Smith,…

The idea Geno Smith will be replaced by backup Michael Vick appears to be all smoke, as the Jets are intent to ride with their second-round draft pick.

NFL

Will Beatty playing like franchise left tackle again…

Left tackle Will Beatty, who is the elder-statesman of Giants’ line, has turned around his season and become a consistent force on Manning’s blindside.

NFL

John Conner back with Jets for second stint

He'll be back. It's "Terminator 2" for the Jets, who brought back John Conner to the team on Tuesday after placing fullback Tommy Bohanon on…

NFL

Fantasy football: Ben Tate to break out, Larry…

Fantasy football: Ben Tate to break out, Larry Donnell will stay solid

Career

Creating a support system for minority women in…

When Kathryn Finney founded digitalundivided — an organization devoted to engaging minority communities with the tech world — she didn’t know quite what to expect.…

Sex

We can learn a lot from animals about…

There’s a lot we can learn about love from the birds and the bees — and the chickens, monkeys and squirrels that we share the…

Style

Saint Laurent

Our review of the Saint Laurent Spring '15 show at Paris Fashion Week.

Style

Céline: Paris Fashion Week Spring 2015

Our review of the Celine Spring '15 show during Paris Fashion Week.