Is stop-and-frisk gone for good?

The decision in Floyd, et al. v City of New York, et al. doesn't abolish stop-and-frisk. Credit: Miles Dixon
The decision in Floyd, et al. v City of New York, et al. doesn’t abolish stop-and-frisk. Credit: Miles Dixon

Some New Yorkers may be wondering whether today’s federal court ruling declaring stop-and-frisk unconstitutional and discriminatory means a ban on the controversial police practice.

That is not the case, according to Baher Azmy, the legal director at the Center for Constitutional Rights, which brought the suit against the city.

“The court makes clear that stop-and-frisk can be a valid law enforcement tool and this in no way prohibits using stop-and-frisk under existing constitutional guidelines,” Azmy explained.

From the start, the lawsuit was not attacking the practice itself: it was specifically pushing for a change in how the NYPD carries out stop-and-frisk.

The court-appointed monitor called for in the judge’s ruling will “oversee a number of reforms that will bring the practice into compliance with the Constitution,” Azmy said.

The reforms will touch on the training of officers, the supervision of officers, the documentation of stops and “other standards of police accountability practices that have been used in dozens of other places.”

Azmy poked holes in the mayor’s assertion that “no federal judge has ever imposed a monitor over a city’s police department following a civil trial.”

Bloomberg also argued that the Department of Justice under the current and past two presidents “never, not once, found reason to investigate the NYPD.”

But the Department of Justice did find reason, following the stop-and-frisk trial, to file a Statement of Interest in the case, in which the DOJ outlined the many other cities and states where a federal monitor has facilitated police reform. In the statement filed exactly two months ago, the DOJ asked the judge to consider mandating a federal monitor over the NYPD in her ruling.

“The mayor mistakes hyperbole for analysis,” Azmy said dryly.

Azmy shrugged off the mayor’s specification of “following a civil trial,” explaining that in other cases in other states and cities, the trial is often brought by the Justice Department, which then finds cause for a monitor to oversee reform of a police department.

“If anything, this is more through because it’s after nine weeks of evidence,” Azmy said, “instead of an investigation by some lawyers at the Justice Department.”

“If anything, this is a sounder process,” he added.

 

Follow Danielle Tcholakian on Twitter @danielleiat



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Federal mediator joins Met Opera labor talks as…

Unions representing the orchestra and chorus of the Met Opera agreed to have a federal mediator join labor talks on Thursday as a threatened lockout loomed.

Local

Winning $7 million New York lottery ticket sold…

The only $7 million winning New York Lottery ticket for Monday's Cash4Life drawing was sold at a Queens 7-Eleven, officials said on Tuesday.

Local

Brooklyn man charged in roommate's stabbing death

A Brooklyn man accused of violently stabbing his roommate to death on Monday is in police custody and faces murder charges.

International

Dinosaurs could have survived asteroid strike

It turns out there is a good and a bad time for the planet to be hit by a meteor, and dinosaurs were just unlucky.…

Movies

Review: 'Guardians of the Galaxy' is a refreshingly…

Marvel is sitting so high on a cash mountain that it's now thrown $170 million at the relatively obscure and very silly title "Guardians of the Galaxy."

Movies

Review: 'Get on Up' is a war between…

James Brown finally gets his own boring biopic with "Get on Up," but the Godfather of Soul puts up a good fight against the usual cliches.

Movies

Review: 'Child of God' finds director James Franco…

James Franco's 11th directed feature is a noble but sloppy adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's "Child of God," about a feral mountain man (Scott Haze).

Movies

Review: Alex Gibney's Fela Kuti doc 'Finding Fela'…

Prolific documentarian Alex Gibney takes on Afrobeat god Fela Kuti in "Finding Fela," but fails to capture his unique essence.

MLB

Yankees land Stephen Drew, Martin Prado at trade…

Yankees land Stephen Drew, Martin Prado at trade deadline

College

Playing the Field: Valentine's Day coupling edition

  It’s Valentine’s Day, a day created by Hallmark to make couples spend loads and loads of money on candy, flowers and gourmet dinners. Or…

MLB

Angelo Cataldi: Ryan Howard deserves better from Phillies

Just last week, Ryan Howard endured the embarrassment of a benching that was inevitable, and yet still shocking.

NFL

Larry Donnell has inside track in Giants tight…

Little-known Larry Donnell of Grambling State currently has the inside track, as the second-year player has received the bulk of the first-team reps.

Career

What do you wear to a career fair?…

Getting that gig starts with presenting the most polished and memorable version of yourself, so refer to our expert fashion advice.

Style

Editors pick: Margiela's finger armor ring

These cool rings from Maison Martin Margiela are designed to overlap over the finger, covering each joint like armor.

Style

Givenchy champions diversity

Riccardo Tisci's uses a variety of ethnically diverse ladies for his spring campaign including Erykah Badu.

Wellbeing

Don't settle for the hotel fitness center with…

Travelers who want to skip the hotel fitness center in favor of local gyms that may offer better equipment, classes and amenities can turn to…