‘Egregious’ misconduct at state drug lab spurs guilty plea reviews

The state drug testing lab in Jamaica Plain was closed after former chemist Annie Dookhan was arrested for evidence tampering. (Nicolaus Czarnecki/Metro)
The state drug testing lab in Jamaica Plain was closed after former chemist Annie Dookhan was arrested for evidence tampering.
Credit: Nicolaus Czarnecki/Metro

The state’s highest court on Wednesday ruled that drug defendants seeking to toss out their guilty pleas can have their cases reviewed because of “egregious” misconduct at a state drug lab.

The unanimous decision by the Supreme Judicial Court focuses on the cases of defendants impacted by the mishandling of drug evidence by convicted former state chemist Annie Dookhan.

“The defendant is entitled to a conclusive presumption that Dookhan’s misconduct occurred in his case, that it was egregious, and that it is attributable to the Commonwealth,” Justice Francis Spina wrote in the decision released Wednesday.

Justices rejected a lower court’s ruling to allow a defendant to withdraw his guilty plea because Dookhan had been involved in testing the drug evidence in his case. Instead, the SJC sent it back to the lower court to determine if a guilty plea would have still been the result.

A lower court judge should determine whether, “the defendant can demonstrate a reasonable probability that had he known of Dookhan’s misconduct, he would not have admitted to sufficient facts and would have insisted on taking his chances at trial,” the ruling said.

Suffolk County District Attorney Dan Conley said that he is confident many defendants would have still pleaded guilty even if they knew ahead of time of Dookhan’s actions.

“Many defendants, we believe, would still have pleaded guilty, and not just in exchange for a reduction in sentencing. The evidence in a drug case is almost never limited just to the drugs: there’s packaging, cutting agents, baggies, cash, phone calls and text messages, and the defendant’s actions before, during, and after the seizure of drug evidence,” Conley said in a statement.

The ruling comes one day after the state’s inspector general released the findings of a 15-month review of the drug lab crisis.

The report said a former state chemist who tampered with drug evidence samples was a “sole bad actor,” but that there were management failures at the lab and that managers there were “ill-suited to oversee a forensic drug lab.”

Follow Michael Naughton on Twitter @metrobosmike.


Dr. Dre is king of hip hop with…

With $620 million in estimated pre-tax earnings, veteran rapper and record producer Dr. Dre topped Forbes list as the highest paid hip hop artist, ousting Sean "Diddy" Combs from the…


Bin Laden son-in-law sentenced to life in U.S.…

A seemingly unrepentant Suleiman Abu Ghaith, a son-in-law of Osama bin Laden, was sentenced to life in prison on Tuesday in New York following his conviction on terrorism charges.


Bloomberg: Going green will grant you longer life…

Former NYC mayor Michael Bloomberg tells Metro that cities are where fighting global warming can make a difference, and increase people’s lifespan.


Ban Ki Moon: "Climate change is an issue…

My message to you is: make your voice heard and your actions count. Change is in the air. Solutions exist. The race is on. It’s time to lead.


Craig Ferguson wants you to see his new…

Craig Ferguson thinks his new game show will become "a comedy show in which a game is played and money is won."


Anthony Anderson on dealing with your 'ish'

Anthony Anderson discusses finding the humor in his "Black-ish" family.


Photos: See who Robert Pattinson was caught holding…

Robert Pattinson has a new girlfriend.

The Word

The Word: Kris and Bruce Jenner's predictably public…

They said it wouldn't last — mostly because of that separation almost a year ago. And now, more than a year later, Kris and Bruce…


Bud Selig honors Derek Jeter as both prepare…

Bud Selig’s 22-year reign as commissioner will end Sunday, and while it’s had its share of negative moments, it also had Derek Jeter.


Column: Geno Smith not the answer for Jets…

There were highs for Jets quarterback Geno Smith in Monday night’s loss to the Bears and there were incredible lows.


3 things that went right in Jets loss…

It wasn't the result the Jets wanted, a 27-19 loss to the Bears, but this team deserves some credit.


Here's the 8 best and worst sporting goodbyes

With Derek Jeter set to retire following the 2014 Major League Baseball season, we look back at some of the great and not-so-great sporting goodbyes.


NYC fall real estate hot list

The upcoming developments and areas everyone's buzzing about.


Milan Fashion Week shows the best of Italian…

Metro rounds up the cut of the collections at Milan Fashion Week.


The 2014 Maker Faire saw robots, printers and…

Got a broken button maker? There’s a fix for that – and Tony Stanzione of the Fixers’ Collective says he can show you how.


First look: Uniqlo's fall/winter 2014 kids collection

Get a sneak peek at Uniqlo's kids and babies fall/winter 2014 line.