Opinion: Major League Baseball replay system shouldn’t be dumped just yet

John Farrell Red Sox
Red Sox manager John Farrell barks at umpires in New York last weekend after coming up on the wrong end of the stick when it comes to MLB’s new replay system. Credit: Getty Images

User errors aside, Major League Baseball’s problem isn’t its new replay system on its own. “Replay issues” are simply what’s on minds of those in our “OH LOOK! A NEW INTERNET MEME!” culture right now. This minute.

Why?

Because Jerry Remy’s son didn’t beat anyone up in prison this week, Papi’s selfie with POTUS is yesterday’s controversy, and Jenny Dell has stayed off of Instagram for a hot minute. It’s because the Red Sox are in the basement of the AL East, but it’s too early to panic; because the Bruins don’t start their playoff push until Game 1 at the Garden Friday night and finally, because the biggest moment of the Celtics season happens on May 20 — well after the games stop, during the NBA Draft Lottery.

To be fair, the Red Sox were victims of the dreaded learning curve against the Yankees last weekend. Two blown calls by umpires using the newly instated replay system resulted in two tough losses to a division foe that could prove costly come September. The spectacle around these blunders was almost surreal – culminating, of course, with John Farrell’s ejection from Sunday night’s nationally televised game after arguing about the shoddy review process that lacked conclusive evidence.


Even worse, this was on the heels MLB’s flimsy explanation of Saturday afternoon’s blown call. The umpires “did not have immediate access to the conclusive angle” in that one. Huh?

You may be thinking to yourself, “It’s 2014. We’re like four years away from telepathic technology – how do the umpires NOT have access to the same angles we’re seeing on television?” And you’re not far off. Remember, this is the same league with official team Facebook pages which are hacked on an alarming basis. Technology and baseball are sworn enemies.

Whether there’s merit to this learning curve existing in the first place is a different argument for a different day. And nothing written in this missive so far illustrates any semblance of confidence that Bud Selig and company will clean things up, and figure this whole replay thing out in the immediate future. Still, while MLB may lack tact, it’s important to avoid combining administrative ineptitude with a concept.

The precept of replay isn’t to fine tune the game by completely removing an umpire’s subjectivity from the equation; it’s to serve as a safeguard which corrects an instantaneous judgment when it’s egregiously wrong. Is the process perfect? Absolutely not, but replay helps sustain the integrity of the game, and if last weekend was a small tariff toward refinement, then so be it.

Catering to the whims of angry fans and the enabling sports media is a dangerous venture. The Red Sox were victims of an unstable process, not a capability. Eliminating the use of replay entirely is irresponsible.

Follow Ryan Hadfield on Twitter @Hadfield__



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

MTA announces service changes for Sunday

The MTA has announced service changes ahead of Sunday's People's Climate March, which will be held from 11:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Sunday. Riders using…

Local

NYPD launches Twitter account for L train

The NYPD recently launched a Twitter handle dedicated to the L train and its riders. According to @NYPDLtrain, officers went underground Thursday morning to hand…

Local

Bushwick community space offers activists a place to…

A new Bushwick community space offers community activists to meet, create, learn and throw back a few cold ones. MayDay, located 214 Starr Street in Bushwick,…

Local

Activists gearing up for Sunday's "historic" People's Climate…

If all goes according to plan, more than 100,000 people will gather near Central Park West on Sunday morning and march through midtown to raise…

Movies

Kevin Smith makes peace with the Internet

I was thinking about Ain't It Cool News and Harry Knowles last night, wondering if anyone from Ain't It Cool had reviewed my new movie…

Movies

Art imitates life in 'Swim Little Fish Swim'

There's a certain comfort to be taken in finding that young artists are still moving to New York and trying to make it — and…

Movies

Review: Terry Gilliam's 'The Zero Theorem' is better…

Terry Gilliam's latest, "The Zero Theorem," concerns a reclusive malcontent (Christoph Waltz) struggling with the search for the meaning of life.

Music

Esperanza Spalding and a being called Emily get…

Esperanza Spalding is about to spiral off in a brand new direction that may or may include an alter ego named Emily.

NFL

Oday Aboushi ready for increased role, and to…

Oday Aboushi might feel comfortable enough to engage in some trash talk the next time he is on the field.

NFL

Giants vs. Texans: 3 things to watch

The Giants host the surprising Texans (2-0) in what may already be a must-win game for Big Blue.

NFL

Eric Decker misses practice again, could miss Monday

Jets wide receiver Eric Decker missed practice Thursday as he continues to rehab a hamstring injury suffered last Sunday.

MLB

Derek Jeter still focused on baseball as final…

Derek Jeter has effectively hid his emotions for 20 years in the Bronx.

Parenting

A sneaky way to serve kids fruits and…

"My First Juices and Smoothies" gives smoothie recipes for kids.

Style

3 things we love from Day 1 of…

The highlights from Day 1 of Milan Fashion Week.

Sex

Why don't more couples use condoms?

  Call it the “condom moment.” That’s the name the authors of a new study have given to the pivotal conversation every couple should be…

Sex

Need an idea for a first date? Here's…

Picture your idea of a nice first date. Is it dinner and a movie? A visit to an interesting museum exhibit? Instead, an expert on…