Can city afford to pay contract terms of firefighters union Local 22?

Local 22 President Bill Gault, center.
RIKARD LARMA/METRO

City Council on Wednesday held a hearing in attempt to pin down the cost to the city of honoring firefighters union Local 22′s four-year contract, originally set to go in effect in July of 2009. “We need to know so we are not caught by surprise,” said Councilman David Oh, who called the meeting. “And have to make payments we cannot plan for, putting taxpayers at risk.”

Mayor Michael Nutter’s administration on Tuesday filed its third appeal of the contract award, claiming the city does not have the funds to cover three years of retroactive wage increases that have now snowballed into a potentially large up-front payout.

“The impact of the award would be substantial,” Finance Director Rob Dubow said. “Over the course of the current five-year plan, it would add more than $200 million in additional costs to the city’s general fund, with the cost this fiscal year alone more than $84 million.”

But others testified that figure is inflated because it includes both the three years of retroactive wages and the cost of Local 22′s compensation package for the next five years.

“It’s part of a five-year plan, but it’s an eight-year calculation because you have the retroactive piece in there,” Councilman Dennis O’Brien said. “To me, with all the other things going on, I can’t help but come to the conclusion there is some sort of a punitive agenda here.”

Local 22′s legal counsel Rick Poulson said the award’s actual cost is closer to $66 million – $34 million in salaries and $32 million in active and retiree medical costs. He believes the city’s figure is high even for an eight-year projection due to other disputed accounting methods.

But Poulson said in the event the award does cost $200 million, it would still not have a major financial impact because that amounts to a mere 1.5 percent of the city’s total $32 billion budget over eight years.

The administration also came under fire for not putting aside any money to pay the award. “Already, the city is in arrears $84 million on a bill they know they have to pay,” City Controller Alan Butkovitz said. “And their answer is this: ‘How about we don’t pay it some more?’”

The administration in August proposed in the city’s five-year fiscal plan to
offset Local 22′s award with a package of two to five percent
across-the-board cuts to all city departments, which they are arguing on appeal would negatively affect key city services.

The savings were outlined
in an 11th hour addendum to the plan after some members of the
Philadelphia Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority expressed
reluctance to approve it because of the contract issue.

“We just know there’s an amount of money spent on something and there’s been no money set aside, which means all of this money is going to be suddenly due,” Oh said to administration representatives. “Being the city has lost two arbitration and a Common Pleas appeal and has now presented all of its evidence, do you believe that you are going to win this appeal and not have to pay anything?”

The Nutter administration and Local 22 have been waging a battle in arbitration and in court over the contract for more than three years. Negotiations begin at the end of this month for Local 22′s next four-year contract.

“The bigger issue is, regardless of whether the contract costs $60 million, $70 million or $200 million, is that the award has now been issued twice and affirmed in court,” said Local 22 President Bill Gault. “Act 111 says these [arbitration] awards are supposed to be final and binding.”


Timeline





July 1, 2009.
Local 22′s contract with the city expired.



Sept. 17, 2010 – Oct. 12, 2010.
The city and Local 22 went to arbitration and a four-year contract was awarded.

Nov. 12, 2010. The city appealed to the Court of Common Pleas.



Nov. 16, 2011.
A Common Pleas judge sent the contract back to arbitration.

July 2, 2012. An arbitration panel awarded virtually the same terms.



July 17, 2012.
Local 22 filed a lawsuit against the city compelling them to implement the contract.

July 27, 2012. The city again appealed the arbitration award to the Court of Common Pleas.

Aug. 9, 2012. PICA delayed its vote on the city’s five-year plan. After some members expressed reluctance to approve the plan without provisions for paying Local 22′s contract, Nutter submitted an addendum of possible cuts.

Sept. 5, 2012. PICA approved the five-year plan, but chairman Sam Katz cautioned he would vote against next year’s plan if the city failed to agree on contracts with municipal unions.

Nov. 21, 2012. A Common Pleas judge upheld the union’s arbitration award.

Dec. 11, 2012. Mayor Michael Nutter’s administration appealed, asking the judge to stay her order. If the judge denies to do so, the city can appeal her denial to the Commonwealth Court.

Dec. 31, 2012. Negotiations begin for Local 22′s next four-year contract, which goes into effect July 1, 2013.


News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
International

'Barack Obama cheats on Michelle' claims Japanese politician…

A senior Japanese politician has marred Barack Obama's official visit to Tokyo with bizarre claims that the President cheats on his wife Michelle. Kazuyuki Hamada,…

International

British Royal family devastated by freak NY death…

The British royals have been left devastated by the death of Mark Shand, younger brother of Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall, after a freak fall in…

Local

Philadelphia principal has President Obama's ear

The West Philadelphia head is gathering ideas to present to the White House.

Local

Neighbors testify at Overbrook roommate slaying trial

Neighbors and roommates were called to testify Wednesday in the trial of Renaldo Robichaw, 56, charged with murder for the death of roommate Albert Smith, 48.

Television

‘Survivor: Cagayan’ recap: Episode 9

It was only an hour-long episode, but there's a lot to cover this week. The drama of Survivor strikes again as the identity of the…

Television

TV watch list, Wednesday, April 23: 'Suburgatory,' 'Modern…

'Suburgatory' The men of "Suburgatory" go camping and Tessa mentors a social outcast in a Miss Chatswin contest, which brings her, once again, into conflict…

Movies

Latin culture highlighted at Filadelphia film fest

Get ready to have a “Bad Hair” day at the upcoming Filadelphia Latin American Film Festival. We mean that in the best possible way. The…

The Word

The best lines from Oprah's ex-stepmother's Daily Mail…

Oprah’s ex-stepmother, Barbara Winfrey, is out for revenge.

NFL

2014 NFL Mock Draft: Updated, new April 24…

2014 NFL Mock Draft: Updated, new April 24 version

NFL

Eagles will spend Thanksgiving in Dallas, play four…

The Eagles have an impressive, challenging and exciting schedule in 2014.

NFL

NFL releases Eagles 2014 schedule

The Eagles have four primetime games, face the Cowboys on Thanksgiving and host the Seahawks in a dynamic, challenging and impressive schedule.

NHL

All signs suggest Steve Mason will start in…

Flyers head coach Craig Berube elected to put Steve Mason in net for the final minutes of Game 3.

Style

Pippa Middleton's Etsy pick: Golden Thread Jewelry

Get a look at the jewelry Pippa Middleton loves and find out how you can buy it too.

Parenting

What every parent needs to know to get…

Mom and author of "Small Talk," Tracey Blake, shares her five practical tips to help you develop your children's language skills.

Sex

Subway crush: Meet your soulmate on your commute

Read about a couple who has been 40 years after meeting on the train.

Tech

Happy birthday, Game Boy! The handheld console turns…

Nintendo's Game Boy turns 25 this week. To commemorate, we look at some of its better games, like "Tetris" and "The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening."