Metro Boston Top 25 of the last 25: Greatest Boston athletes

Metro Boston Top 25 cover by Gina Angelotti.
Metro Boston Top 25 cover by Gina Angelotti.

Metro Boston recently polled its readers, writers and various Boston sports media on which Boston athletes of the past 25 years are the undisputed greatest.

Current Patriots quarterback Tom Brady edged out Celtics legend Larry Bird and Red Sox great Pedro Martinez to land the No. 1 spot overall. Here were the rules:

• Athlete must have played for the Bruins, Celtics, Patriots or Red Sox in the past 25 years (1988-2013).
• Athlete must have played for a Boston team for at least three seasons in the past 25 years. Example: Gary Payton or Shaquille O’Neal would not be eligible.
• Historical significance, tenure, time period, championships won are all factors.

Here is the final list based exclusively on feedback. To view the dreaded “snubs” list, click here.

1. Tom Brady - Out of all the responses Metro received, only three people DID NOT have No. 12 ranked No. 1. Brady played his entire prime in the time period allotted, racked up three Super Bowl wins, appeared in five Big Games total and led New England to the first 16-0 regular season in NFL history in 2007. Is there a case to be made for someone else? Yes says WEEI’s Kirk Minihane.

“Here’s the thing – The Bird from 1988 until he retired has nothing close to Brady’s resume. But if I’m filling out any list that has Bird as an option he is always numero uno. Always. Could be best singers of the Motown Era and he’d still take top spot.”

For Minihane’s Top 25, click here.

2. Larry Bird - WEEI’s Mike Mutnansky dropped those whose “greatness” came mostly prior to 1988, thus the reason Bird fell to No. 3 on his list. But Bird was still great in his twilight, averaging 24.3 ppg in 75 games in 1989-90. For Mutnansky’s Top 25, click here.

3. Pedro Martinez - 98.5 The Sports Hub’s Marc Bertrand put Pedro ahead of Bird, and one can certainly make that case considering all of Martinez’s best years came in the late 1990s. Pedro captured a pair of Cy Young Awards in Boston. For Bertrand’s Top 25, click here.

4. Ray Bourque - Bourque retired from hockey with 410 goals and 1,169 assists in 1,612 games played in the NHL. Not too shabby for a defenseman. Number 77 played in 19 straight NHL All-Star games and was the face of the franchise throughout the 1990s.

5. Cam Neely - Metro writer Tony Lee gave Neely a boost for his recent job as Bruins president. Not too bad a player either as he basically invented the power forward position in the NHL.

6. Paul Pierce - The wounds are fresh but No. 34 will be hanging in the rafters.

7. Kevin McHale - The man who re-defined post play in the NBA made the East All-Star team every year from 1988-91.

8. Roger Clemens - “The Rocket” won the Cy Young Award in 1991 before bolting town in 1996.

9 . Adam Vinatieri - “Mr. Clutch” had two Super Bowl-winning kicks but his greatest may have come in the 2002 “Snow Bowl.”

10. Manny Ramirez - Arguably the best hitter in baseball during his Boston years (2001-08) and the MVP of the 2004 World Series.

11. Ty Law - Law picked off an in-his-prime Peyton Manning three times in the 2003 AFC Championship Game.

12. Kevin Garnett -
“KG” turned the Celtics franchise around when he arrived via trade during the summer of 2007. The former league MVP averaged 18.8 points per game in the 2007-08 championship season and gave the C’s a vaunted defense.

13. Tim Thomas - They say a hot goaltender can lead you to a Stanley Cup. Never was that more true in 2011 when “Timmy” got hot at just the right time. His performances in the B’s three Game 7s that postseason were things of legend. Thomas was a Boston goaltender from 2002-03 through the 2011-12 seasons and won 196 games.

14. David Ortiz - Ortiz’s placement in the middle of the list seemed a bit too low for Metro writer Ryan Hannable, but many dropped Big Papi because of his inclusion on a 2009 PED list. Still, Ortiz’s homer in Game 4 of the 2004 ALCS wil live on forever.

15. Curt Schilling - Schilling made good on his promise to break the supposed “Curse of the Bambino” and the image of his “bloody sock” will live on forever in the minds of Boston sports fans. Schilling finished second in AL Cy Young voting in 2004.

16. Vince Wilfork - A five-time Pro Bowler, Wilfork has been the anchor of the Patriots defense almost since the day he arrived in 2004 out of the University of Miami. A beast in the middle of the Pats d-line, Wilfork helped power New England to an undefeated regular season in 2007.

17. Wade Boggs — The hit machine was an All-Star for the Sox from 1988-1992 and finished his career with over 3,000 hits.

18. Tedy Bruschi — The heart and soul of the Pats championship defense. Number 54 went to five Super Bowls with New England, including the loss to the Packers in the 1996 season.

19. Richard Seymour — Seymour recorded eight sacks in both the 2003 season and 2008 season.

20. Dustin Pedroia — Boston’s new $100 million man won the 2008 AL MVP.

21. Wes Welker — Welker had three straight 110-reception seasons.

22. Zdeno Chara — “Big Z” continues to anchor the Bruins’ defense

23. Drew Bledsoe - In the words of Metro reader Stephen Sabourin, Bledsoe “revived the Patriots franchise” before injuries and Tom Brady booted him to Buffalo. In just his second pro season in 1994, No. 11 tossed for more yards (4,555) than any QB in the league.

24. Reggie Lewis - There’s no telling how much higher the late Lewis could have been on this list. The silky-smooth shooting guard was considered by many to be the second best 2-guard behind Michael Jordan in the early 1990s.

25. Ben Coates – Coates was a bruising tight end in the 1990s and was, without question, Drew Bledsoe’s security blanket in the Pats passing game. A five-time Pro Bowler, Coates caught 96 passes in 1994, which was then an NFL record for a tight end.

Got beef with the list and want to vent? Send your feedback to Metro Boston sports editor Matt Burke on Twitter @BurkeMetroBOS or by e-mail at matthew.burke@metro.us

Hear WEEI’s analysis of Metro’s list here:

Watch this at WEEI



News
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Local

Astoria minivan crash kills 1, injures 6: NYPD

Anthony Boyd, 45, died soon after what investigators believe was some sort of medical emergency as he drove his family through Astoria on Sunday afternoon.

Local

NYC pension funds valued at $160b: Scott Stringer

The five NYC pension funds that thousands of city employees contribute to saw its fifth year in a row of increased returns, up $23 billion from last year.

Local

Man dies trapped in elevator shaft at Bronx…

A man in his twenties died after being trapped in an elevator shaft of a Bronx building early Monday, police said.

International

Sierra Leone Ebola patient, recovered from family, dies…

An Ebola patient whose family sparked a nationwide hunt when they forcefully removed her from a treatment center and took her to a traditional healer has died.

Music

Newport Folk Festival: Photo gallery of 35 moments…

As has been the tradition since Bob Dylan plugged in a bajillion years ago, the Newport Folk Festival embraces more musical genres than its name implies.

Music

MKTO: Behind the bromance

MKTO's Malcolm Kelley and Tony Oller talk about the American Dream tour, Demi Lovato and getting turned down by girls.

Arts

James Earl Jones and Rose Byrne head to…

Two-time Tony winner James Earl Jones returns to the New York stage next month as an eccentric grandfather in a revival of the 1930s comedy…

Movies

Box office: Scarlett Johansson wins battle of brains…

Scarlett Johansson's "Lucy" handily dispatched with Dwayne Johnson's "Hercules" over the weekend.

MLB

Yankees looking to trade for Josh Willingham: Report

CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman reported Sunday the Yankees are interested in Twins outfielder Josh Willingham.

MLB

Joe Torre: I'm in Hall of Fame because…

Joe Torre spent 18 years putting together a near Hall of Fame career as a player. But it was the 12 years he spent as…

MLB

Yankees GM Brian Cashman breaks down art of…

The action frequently accelerates as the non-waiver trade deadline approaches, as it will on Thursday.

Auto racing

Jeff Gordon captures fifth title at Brickyard 400

Jeff Gordon captures fifth title at Brickyard 400

Tech

Amazon offers 3D printing to customize earrings, bobble…

By Deepa SeetharamanSAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Amazon.com Inc will offer 3D printing services that allow customers to customize and build earrings, bobble head toys and…

Wellbeing

This Week In Health: Friends share similar DNA,…

Friends share similar DNA, study finds Location: U.S. Study subjects: Nearly 2,000 people Results: When it comes to our social networks, it seems that birds of…

Education

Are liberal arts colleges turning away from the…

Bryn Mawr College, a small women's college located just outside of Philadelphia, announced last week that it would be making standardized tests like the SAT…

Education

Recent grads discover school superintendent plagiarized parts of…

  Two recent high school graduates made a surprising discovery about the commencement speech their school superintendent delivered at their graduation: portions of it was copied…