BOSTON. A panel of nationally recognized scientists found that a federal review of the safety of the controversial Boston University biolab did not thoroughly analyze the risks to the South End community where it is being built.
The study, by the highly respected National Research Council, discredits the federal government’s draft risk assessment of the lab, which found it posed no threat to the densely populated community. The study called the assessment incomplete and insufficient in determining the affect the facility will have on the inner-city population.
This revelation adds serious momentum to the neighborhood’s four-year fight to stop the project.
“This is a great vindication to the residents,” said Laura Maslow-Armand, a staff attorney with the Lawyers committee for Civil Rights under Law, one of the attorneys representing several groups fighting the lab. “If you don’t have the risk adequately analyzed, it’s discriminatory — it’s a violation of the civil rights of the community.”
The NRC study, which was released yesterday, claims the initial assessment done by the National Institutes of Health was “not sound and credible” and did not adequately identify, nor thoroughly develop, worst-case scenarios for the release and spread of a pathogen.
The NRC study was commissioned by the Massachusetts Executive Office of Environmental Affairs after a state judge earlier this year ordered a further review of the project. There are currently both state and federal lawsuits pending to halt the lab construction.
The Executive Office of Environmental Affairs has a large say in whether the biolab, which will test the most dangerous pathogens in the world, such as Ebola and anthrax, will be given the green light. The $200 million lab is halfway complete and is largely funded by the NIH as part of the Bush administration’s national effort to fight bioterrorism.
The study released yesterday only commented on NIH’s draft risk assessment. The scientists involved in the study did not determine whether or not the lab is safe for the community. NIH and Boston University are expected to release a final report to the court.
Ian Bowles, the state secretary of environmental affairs, said yesterday he hopes this latest NRC study will be useful to NIH in preparing their final report.
NIH released a statement yesterday saying it will consider the comments by the NRC.