There was a time – 1976 – when a play that poked fun at three superficially similar Texas cheerleaders and their divergent life paths created a sensation off-Broadway. While hardly edgy, “Vanities” was fresh, and, at the time, insightful. The comedy, which challenged traditional feminine ideals, was topical.
Fast forward to 2009 to the Second Stage Theatre, where “Vanities, A New Musical” is currently in residence. Talk about a misnomer — there is nothing new about this musical. Yes, a generic score has been slapped on, and Jack Heifner (who wrote both the play and the musical’s book) has reworked some material. But the peppy preppies have exceeded their shelf-lives.
Of the three, Joanne (Sarah Stiles) is the most traditional: the married life is what she wants and gets. Kathy (Anneliese van der Pol) is highly organized but learns that life isn’t. Mary (Lauren Kennedy), the “slutty” one, ends up running an erotic art gallery. But all they do is evolve from one stereotype to another.
It’s hard to invest in any of these paper-thin characters, whose overriding personality traits are underscored by Joseph G. Aulisi’s costumes. Judith Ivey’s direction is efficient but doesn’t provide any of the wit that’s so sorely needed.
‘Vanities, A New Musical’
Through Aug. 9
Second Stage Theatre
307 W. 43rd St.
$30-$75, 212-246-4422
www.2ST.com