American Idol runner-up Adam Lambert’s fans are getting more risqué with the gifts they toss on stage.

What started with bras and glow-in-the-dark handcuffs reached a new level recently when a fan in Hamilton, Ont., threw a dildo onstage during his performance of Whole Lotta Love, according to Showbiz Spy.

Without missing a beat, Lambert kicked the sex toy back into the audience. Lambert previously told Entertainment Weekly that he doesn’t mind the attention: “It’s really getting creative. It’s exciting. I think they really want me to play with these toys during the number.”

But he admits he’s been trying to ignore the gifts because he “didn’t want to condone the behaviour.”