Looks like a little quip may have gotten Anne Hathaway a new nemesis: The Rachel Getting Married star was overheard joking to friends, “I’m like Jennifer Aniston. I pick the wrong guys,” according to the National Enquirer.

When word got back to Aniston about it, she was reportedly less than pleased: “Say what you like ... I’ve never dated con men or criminals,” Aniston is said to have said, referring to Hathaway’s ex-fiancé, an Italian businessman snagged by the FBI last year.