Buoyant German economic growth will be tough to sustain

By Michael Nienaber

By Michael Nienaber


BERLIN (Reuters) - A “golden decade” of growth and prosperity in Germany risks fading if the government fails to heed calls to increase investment and pursue structural reforms that lay the foundations for a new phase of economic expansion.


Europe's economic powerhouse grew at the fastest rate in half a decade last year, but it is unlikely to top this performance in 2017 and beyond.


A consumption-led upswing looks to have reached its peak as a slowdown in wage growth and a pick-up in inflation gradually weakensconsumers' spending power.


Meanwhile exports - long the mainstay of growth - could also weaken givenpolitical uncertainties such as Brexit and a possible protectionist U.S. trade policyunder Donald Trump.

Germany's economy grew by 1.9 percent in 2016 driven by soaring private consumption, increased state spending on refugees and higher construction investment, data showed on Thursday.

But analysts polled by Reuters expect economic growth to slow to 1.4 percent in 2017 and 1.5 percent in 2018, with inflation predicted to bounce back to 1.6 percent this year.

"German private and public consumption will rise less dynamically in 2017," Ifo economist Timo Wollmershaeuser said, pointing to the higher oil price and a reduced number of refugee arrivals.

Meanwhile, real wages for workers with collective agreements rose less sharply in 2016 than in the previous two years, a study showed last week.

ING's Carsten Brzeski said that German real wages would not continue to rise and interest rates would not be cut further.

"The simple lack of additional stimulus means that growth should slow down. Not only in 2017 but also in the year beyond," Brzeski said, adding that household and state spending would continue to drive growth - only at a somewhat slower pace.


Germany has enjoyed an economic super-cycle, kicked-off by the economic reforms from Chancellor Angela Merkel's predecessor Gerhard Schroeder and prolonged by the European Central Bank's ultra-loose monetary policy, a weak euro and lower oil prices.

Under Schroeder, Germany cut income tax, reduced non-wage labor costs such as employer healthcare contributions and made it easier for firms to hire and fire workers.

However economists and senior German officials say a new wave of changes are needed: to improve the country's infrastructure, underpin the pension system for an ageing population and meet the challenges of digitalization.

They say the government should increase female participation in the labor market by getting rid of tax incentives for parents staying at home, introduce part-time work schemes, and provide better child care.

Other demands include strengthening English language skills for children and investing in high-speed internet and digital infrastructure that put Germany on par with world leaders.

If the government fails to pursue such reforms, business leaders say the "golden era" of growth and prosperity risks fading.

While the government has increased investment more than the euro zone average in recent years due to healthy tax revenues and record-low borrowing costs, the private sector is holding back amid rising political uncertainty.

"What the upswing is missing is a contribution from industry," Ifo's Wollmershaeuser said, adding that companies were not investing enough in equipment and machinery.

"There is no impulse from abroad that could turn this upswing into a boom," he added.

BDI President Dieter Kempf said this week that future growth was anything but self-evident, given the political challenges threatening Germany.

German business leaders are worried that the economy could face headwinds from a protectionist U.S. trade policy under new president Trump and excessive state interference in China.

"Strong export growth will not return," Commerzbank analyst Joerg Kraemer said, arguing that demand from China would remain weak and the benefits from past trade liberalizations had been reaped while protectionist sentiment prevented new trade deals.


There are also structural problems which may prevent German exports from propelling growth strongly as before.

"The German government is rolling back the labor market reforms of the former Chancellor Schroeder which is weakening the competitiveness of the German economy," Kraemer said.

German wages rose much more strongly than productivity in 2016, meaning that unit labor costs increased for the fourth consecutive year, the Federal Statistics Office said.

The Cologne Institute for Economic Research warned that this trend is hurting German companies' export performance and increasing the risk of losing market share.

A global shift away from traditional manufacturing towards services is also a problem - the latter not being a German strength.

"Combined with a general tendency towards more protectionism, it is hard to see that German exports will easily return to old strength," ING's Brzeski concluded.

To lay the foundations for more growth, experts such as the government's panel of economic advisers have repeatedly urged the government to encourage private investment through fresh reforms.

But Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble on Thursday suggested using last year's federal budget surplus of 6.2 billion euros to amortize old debt instead of increasing investment.

"In the long run, these problems will hit back and lower growth in Germany," Commerzbank's Kraemer said.

(Editing by Toby Chopra)

Latest From ...
Most Popular From ...