With the World Series under his belt, Alex Rodriguez is reportedly ready to take on his next challenge: proposing to girlfriend Kate Hudson.

“He’s been talking about proposing quite a bit lately,” a source tells OK! magazine.

“He wants to think of a creative and cute way to pop the question.” And the couple, who have been inseparable for months, have even been joking around about tying the knot. “Kate loves to say, ‘I don’t look like a Rodriguez — you’ll have to take my name,’” the source says.