Premier opposes black-focused schools



aaron harris/torstar news service


Premier Dalton McGuinty, shaking hands with an audience member at a Toronto event yesterday, does not support the idea of a black-focused school.


By 16, more than half of all young black males in Toronto public schools have fallen behind. They don’t have the required credits — 16 by age 16 — which means they’re more likely to drop out.

That statistic alone had Trustee Michael Coteau rethinking his opposition to black-focused schools.

"I was brought up in the public system, a very multicultural system, and I think it’s important for young people to interact with other cultures. However, when I see those numbers, there’s a failure, a breach in the system. Something’s gone wrong," said Coteau, 35, one of two black trustees on the Toronto District School Board.

Later this month, the board is expected to debate opening a black-focused school. But the premier has already weighed in, saying while the board is free to make its own decision, he doesn’t support it.

"I’m not personally comfortable with that," Dalton McGuinty said yesterday at a Rexdale community centre. "But I think our shared responsibility ... is to look for ways to bring people together. One of those most powerful agents of social cohesion ... is through publicly funded education."

Black-focused schools have long been a controversial issue in Ontario — critics say they segregate students. But supporters say it’s a way to keep black students engaged.

"Desperate times call for desperate action," said David Watkins, who just last week won a Governor General’s teaching award for his black history

classes at Weston Collegiate Institute.

The Toronto board has been piloting several "Africentric" social studies units in Grades 6, 7 and 8 in some schools and run an Africentric summer camp.

For Coteau, however, it’s now time to do more. "I can count more people who died from violent crime in Flemingdon Park than graduated from university," Coteau said of friends in the Toronto neighbourhood where he grew up.

torstar news service

He said it was only when, as a teen, he transferred to Leaside High School that his future changed. "Expectations were placed on me," he said. "The difference between a lot of young people is that some have to live down to expectations and some have to live up."

In fact, one of the key recommendations parents have made to the board is that an African-centred school emphasize leadership and prepare students to see university as their first choice.

However, Zanana Akande, the first black woman elected to the Ontario legislature and the first in Canada to serve as a cabinet minister, said she understands the sentiment of black-focused school supporters who feel the public system’s curriculum omits much of their history, contributions to society and learning styles — but it’s not something she supports.

"The situation in which we live, work and raise our kids is not a segregated one, it’s an integrated one," said Akande.

Harold Brathwaite, former director of education at the Peel public board, said when he worked with the Toronto board 20 years ago, such an idea was rejected. Instead, the board provided "transition schools for students who came in from overseas and had difficulties adjusting to a new education system, but within 18 months they would be transferred into their own local school."

That, along with homework clubs and after-school programming, would be "better than schools of one particular racial or ethnic group."

With files from Robert Benzie, David Grossman and Daniel Girard.

the proposed plan

  • The "Africentric" school would teach students from junior kindergarten to Grade 8. It would have more black teachers and mentors, a focus on students’ heritage and more parent involvement.