Some business make layoffs the last option
Even as the recession cuts deeply into their revenue, some companiesare opting to do the unconventional: They're keeping all theiremployees and finding other ways to trim costs.
Even as the recession cuts deeply into their revenue, some companies
are opting to do the unconventional: They're keeping all their
employees and finding other ways to trim costs.
Their strategy isn't about mercy. It's built on the notion that layoffs bring high costs and hassles of their own.
at Costco Wholesale Corp. are down 27 percent from a year ago, but the
discount store has not laid anyone off. The only workers let go have
been holiday seasonal hires.
To trim costs, Costco imposed a
hiring freeze at its corporate offices. But the company says it
recognizes that labor remains its most valuable — if costliest —
"We're certainly sharpening our pencil everywhere we
can," said Bob Nelson, Costco's vice president of financial planning
and investor relations. Nelson couldn't recall any layoffs at Costco
since the closing of some stores in the 1980s.
that have avoided layoffs are the exception, not the rule. Employers
have cut 5.1 million jobs since the recession began, including 663,000
last month alone.
Economists say it's a wise move for some companies to keep their workers and cut elsewhere.
you overshoot on the downside and lay off workers, it puts the company
at a disadvantage when the economy comes back to life," said Sean
Snaith, economics professor at the University of Central Florida.
other steps companies are taking to cut costs are not exactly harmless
to workers. Chief among them: capping the number of hours employees can
work, cutting or freezing pay and suspending matching payments to
Casino operator Wynn Resorts is trimming pay and
cutting back on retirement fund matches. Credit agency Equifax Inc.
froze pay for all U.S. employees for 2009 and at some of its foreign
offices as well.
A survey by job placement firm Challenger, Gray
& Christmas this year found 71 percent of companies polled had laid
off some workers. More than a quarter had implemented pay freezes or
Despite the alarming job losses nationwide, John
Challenger, the firm's CEO, said it's more common now than in past
recessions for companies to find other paths to savings than laying
That's because many companies have concluded that
layoffs could be costlier down the road. Employers who have laid people
off have to find, hire and train new ones when the economy recovers.
Workers with specialized skills or strong customer contacts aren't
Marvin Windows and Doors, a Minnesota company,
hasn't laid off any of its 5,300 workers — despite the collapse of the
housing market. Its sales were flat in 2008 and have fallen this year.
"We can't easily replace skilled craftspeople and their decades of experience," said Susan Marvin, president of the company.
Marvin Windows and Doors has trimmed the time factory workers are on
the clock — from 40 hours a week to 32. It's a sacrifice David
Peterson, who is 56 and has worked there for five years, is willing to
"You may have your hours cut, and that's not easy," said
Peterson, who maintains machinery for the company. "But you still have
your job, which gives me a lot of peace of mind."
typically mean companies have to pay severance costs, which vary widely
by occupation and industry. A retail clerk, for instance, might cost a
company $1,000 in severance. A low-level white-collar manager paid
$50,000 a year could get $5,000.
And higher-paid professionals
who earn well into six figures — accountants and lawyers — could get
$50,000 in severance, estimated Terry Connelly, dean of Golden Gate
University's Ageno School of Business in San Francisco.
also are other costs that are harder to put a price tag on, including
the loss of talent and leadership. Layoffs can drag down the morale of
those who managed to survive the job cuts but fear they could be next.
when it comes time to rehire people, a company usually ends up paying a
new hire more than what the laid-off worker got paid. That's because an
improved job market gives workers more negotiating power than if they'd
remained at the company, Connelly said.
Some companies that have
had layoffs say they've done so in targeted ways. Many have decided
they can't cut any more. Defense contractor ITT Corp., for example,
plans to cut about 1,200 jobs, mostly factory and office staff.
are certainly not looking to cut engineering positions, because of how
valuable those jobs are and how difficult they are to replace," said
spokesman Andy Hilton.
Manufacturing has been clobbered by the
recession. The industry lost 161,000 jobs in March and has lost 1.5
million since the recession began. But "a lot of these companies are
hitting the limit of where they'd like to be," said Craig Giffi, U.S.
head of consumer and industrial products at Deloitte LLP.
lathe operators to specialists in computer-controlled industrial
machinery, some manufacturers have made costly investments in skilled
workers and want to keep them.
"When you have talent that is
really special, and you know what you got — it would be costly to let
them go," said economist Ken Mayland, president of ClearView Economics.
say unemployment, now at 8.5 percent nationwide, could climb above 10
percent by year's end. Some economists say the labor market may not
return to normal, meaning a jobless rate of about 5 percent, until 2013.
And once the economy rebounds, companies that didn't slash payrolls could emerge with an edge.
don't want to lay off 15 percent of your work force, because you want
to be prepared to move quickly when the economy turns around, and that
will obstruct your ability to do so," said Dean Baker, co-director of
the liberal-leaning Center For Economic Policy and Research.
Associated Press Writers Mae Anderson and Michelle Chapman in New York and Donna Borak in Washington contributed to this report.