WASHINGTON – We can’t get no job satisfaction.
Even Americans who are lucky enough to have work in this economy are becoming more unhappy with their jobs, according to a new survey that found only 45 per cent of Americans are satisfied with their work.
That was the lowest level ever recorded by the Conference Board research group in more than 22 years of studying the issue. In 2008, 49 per cent of those surveyed reported satisfaction with their jobs.
The drop in workers’ happiness can be partly blamed on the worst recession since the 1930s, which made it difficult for some people to find challenging and suitable jobs. But worker dissatisfaction has been on the rise for more than two decades.
“It says something troubling about work in America. It is not about the business cycle or one grumpy generation,” says Linda Barrington, managing director of human capital at the Conference Board, who helped write the report, which was released Tuesday.
Workers have grown steadily more unhappy for a variety of reasons:
-Fewer workers consider their jobs to be interesting.
-Incomes have not kept up with inflation.
-The soaring cost of health insurance has eaten into workers’ take-home pay.
If the job satisfaction trend is not reversed, economists say, it could stifle innovation and hurt America’s competitiveness and productivity. And it could make unhappy older workers less inclined to take the time to share their knowledge and skills with younger workers.
Nate Carrasco, 26, of Odesa, Texas, says he’s been pretty unhappy in most of his jobs, including his current one at an auto parts store.
“There is no sense of teamwork in most places any more,” Carrasco gripes.
When the Conference Board’s first survey was conducted in 1987, most workers – 61 per cent – said they were happy in their jobs. The survey of 5,000 households was conducted for the Conference Board by TNS, a global market research company.
One clue that may explain workers’ growing dissatisfaction: Only 51 per cent now find their jobs interesting – another low in the survey’s 22 years. In 1987, nearly 70 per cent said they were interested in their work.
Workers who find their jobs interesting are more likely to be innovative and to take the calculated risks and the initiative that drive productivity and contribute to economic growth, Barrington says.
“What’s really disturbing about growing job dissatisfaction is the way it can play into the competitive nature of the U.S. work force down the road and on the growth of the U.S. economy – all in a negative way,” says Lynn Franco, another author of the report and director of the Conference Board’s Consumer Research Center.
Conference Board officials and outside economists suggested that weak wage growth helps explain why workers’ unhappiness has been rising for more than 20 years. After growing in the 1980s and 1990s, average household incomes adjusted for inflation have been shrinking since 2000.
Also, compared with 1980, three times as many workers contribute to the cost of their health insurance – and those contributions have gone up. The average employee contribution for single-coverage medical care benefits rose from $48 a month to $76 a month between 1999 and 2006.
Workers under 25 expressed the highest level of dissatisfaction. Roughly 64 per cent of workers under 25 say they were unhappy in their jobs. The recession has been especially hard on young workers, who face fewer opportunities now and lower wages, some analysts say.
The most satisfied were those ages 25 to 34, who may see some opportunities for upward mobility as baby boomers retire. Around 47 per cent of workers 25 to 34 say they were happy in their jobs.
Some other key findings of the survey:
-Forty-three per cent of workers feel secure in their jobs. In 2008, 47 per cent said they feel secure in their jobs, while 59 per cent felt that way in 1987.
-Fifty-six per cent say they like their co-workers, slightly less than the 57 per cent who said so last year but down from 68 per cent in 1987.
-Fifty-six per cent say they are satisfied with their commute to work even as commute times have grown longer over the years. That compares with 54 per cent in 2008 and 63 per cent in 1987.
-Fifty-one per cent say their are satisfied with their boss. That’s down from 55 per cent in 2008 and around 60 per cent two decades ago.
Carrasco said he wishes his bosses would take time to listen to workers’ ideas – and their difficulties on the job.
“Most of the time they only listen to what their bosses are saying,” he says. “Bosses need to come down to the employee level more and see what actually goes on, versus what their paperwork tells them is happening in the stores.”
It wouldn’t be fair to blame low job satisfaction solely on bad bosses, Barrington says.
“It is two-way responsibility,” she says. “Workers also have to figure out what they should be doing to be the most engaged in their jobs and the most productive.”