The last three movies John Gallagher Jr. have made have been genre. That’s odd for him. Before he co-starred in last year’s “10 Cloverfield Lane,” he was a strictly serious actor. He was on “The Newsroom.” He made indies and dramas like “Margaret” and “Short Term 12.” He did Eugene O’Neill’s “Long Day’s Journey into Night” on Broadway. All of a sudden he was in the semi-sequel to “Cloverfield,” then the horror film “Hush.”
Now he’s in “The Belko Experiment,” a bloody thriller about an office building in Colombia whose employees are trapped inside and forced to kill each other to survive. Gallagher, 32, plays an employee who definitely doesn’t want to turn to murder.
It must have been something going from Eugene O’Neill to a movie where the backs of people’s heads are blown up by little implanted bombs.
[Laughs] It’s funny: I was a big horror-head when I grew up. It took me a few years to conquer my fear of then. I used to go through the horror aisle of the video store, looking at the back of VHS boxes and going, ‘Oh my god, that looks unbelievably scary. I never want to see that.’
When I was 12 or 13, I actually started watching horror movies. But I wasn’t obsessed with gore and blood and guts. The kind of horror movies that really got me were some of the more artistically forward ones, like the early John Carpenter stuff and, of course, a lot of Alfred Hitchcock. I always dreamed of being able to do those kinds of movies.
What made people want to finally cast you in more genre fare, do you think?
A lot of the directors I came across who’ve done horror have said that when they watched “The Newsroom,” they felt I grounded some of the stakes and the dialogue in the show. They thought, "I’d love to put this guy in some extreme situations, to see how he reacts to that."
Do you change up your approach at all?
I approach everything the same way, really. I approach Eugene O’Neill the same way I approach something like “The Belko Experiment.” They’re very different pieces, of course, but I always ask, “What does this guy want? What is he trying to do? How do I tell the truth within this story and make it real, make it believable, interesting?” But certainly doing four hours of Eugene O’Neill on stage is a little different from going to Colombia and being covered in fake blood every day. [Laughs]
I mean, it’s almost the same experience, in a way, I guess?
You feel equally beat up at the end of the day. [Laughs]
Horror’s a great genre for slipping in deep philosophical questions or transgressive ideas.
Those are my favorite ones. A movie like “Belko,” even at the height of the absurdity, it’s still based around this moral conundrum of “Gosh, what would I do?” We all think that when the chips are down, we’ll all become a certain type of individual. But there’s no real way to know that.
Just think about Jordan Horowitz, the “La La Land” producer, at the Oscars: He was able, in a matter of seconds, to do the absolute right thing when he found out “Moonlight” had won Best Picture. That’s crazy.
Because it happens in the blink of an eye. You have the blink of an eye to make a quick, intense decision. It’s masterful to see that — to see somebody work through something super complicated and tricky and heavy in about six seconds. [Laughs]
It’s inspiring and also depressing, because I know, push comes to shove, I wouldn’t have calmly taken charge like that.
I’d just fall on the floor and start crying. [Laughs]